Christian Aid: Blowing The Whistle: Time’s Up For Financial Secrecy
May 11th, 2010
May 11th, 2010
Manchester United tops a Football Secrecy League published in May 2010 by international development agency Christian Aid to highlight the secrecy offered by tax havens, and its potential for harm. Report pdf here.
The league shows the extent of secrecy in top-flight football in the UK. Christian Aid has established that 25 clubs are now based offshore. These include 15 in the English Premier League, six in the Championship, two in League One and two in the Scottish Premier League.
The secrecy league features in a hard-hitting new report – Blowing the Whistle: Time’s Up for Financial Secrecy – which was published as Christian Aid Week, the agency’s annual fund raising drive, got under way.
Christian Aid says that the same tax-haven secrecy which enables some club owners to hide their financial affairs, and even their identities, from supporters, also facilitates massive tax dodging in poor countries.
In football, tax-haven secrecy can jeopardise the very existence of much-loved clubs, hiding the true state of owners’ finances from supporters and creditors alike until the money runs out. In the developing world, tax dodging by individuals and unscrupulous companies trading across borders costs lives.
Christian Aid estimates that as a consequence of financial secrecy, developing countries lose around US$160bn in trade-related tax dodging every year. If the money were used according to current spending patterns, it could yearly save the lives of 350,000 children under the age of five.
In its report, Christian Aid joins forces with the Football Supporters’ Federation and sports ownership and governance group Supporters Direct to highlight the damage that financial secrecy can cause, and demand urgent reform.
‘The money lost to poor countries as a result of tax dodging by companies either trading independently, or as part of multinational groups, is around one and a half times the size of the international aid budget,’ said Christian Aid chief policy adviser Alex Cobham. ‘It is a scandal that must be stopped.
‘Football may seem an unusual subject for Christian Aid to tackle. And an alliance between a development agency and organisations representing the interests of football fans is also out of the ordinary.
‘But we want to draw attention to the widespread damage financial secrecy can cause. And Supporters Direct and the Football Supporters’ Federation share that concern – hence their open letter in the report calling for reform.’
To arrive at the Football Secrecy League, Christian Aid endeavoured to find the true owners of every club in the English, Scottish and Welsh leagues, as well as the Irish League in Northern Ireland and the League of Ireland in the Republic of Ireland.
Rankings were arrived at by multiplying components based on an ‘Opacity Score’ reflecting the secrecy offered by the tax haven where each club is based, and the average figure for attendance at home games, to indicate the number of club stakeholders (its supporters) routinely denied information about the club. (See Page 36 of the report).
Manchester United heads the league because although the identities of its owners – the Glazer family from the US – are seemingly known, full details of their business empire remain a tax-haven mystery. The companies that actually own the club are based in Nevada in the United States, a state that allows companies to keep secret the details of who profits most from their activities (their beneficial owners).
Second and third in the league were Tottenham Hotspur, which is based in the Bahamas, and Manchester City, ownership of which lies in Abu Dhabi.
Dave Boyle, Chief Executive of Supporters Direct, said: ‘It is not good enough to say that no laws are being broken by the anonymity of club owners or the use of opaque ownership structures. What is being broken is something far more fundamental for football: the bond of trust between communities and the people who own the clubs.’
Malcolm Clarke, Chair of the Football Supporters’ Federation, said: ‘If football clubs stopped being customers of tax havens, and legal secrecy hide-outs, the loss of trade would not be noticed. But the power of such a statement of solidarity with their devoted fans in Africa would be incredible.’
Alex Cobham of Christian Aid added: ‘We are not suggesting that anything illicit or untoward is taking place in the football clubs identified in the report. Our concern is that the opaque nature of tax havens, or secrecy jurisdictions, masks the truth, whether or not there is anything to hide.’
The report also contains a Financial Secrecy World Cup table featuring countries that in a month’s time will take part in the tournament in South Africa. Points were awarded to those offering the greatest financial secrecy and deducted from those that lose tax revenue as a result of financial secrecy. The eventual winner was Switzerland, after a close finish with the United States. (England was knocked out by Germany).
‘A number of countries that qualified for the World Cup are tax havens. The Financial Secrecy World Cup was included to draw attention to their activities and to show the global nature of the problem,’ said Alex Cobham.
Reforms called for by Christian Aid are:
• Country-by-country reporting, that would require companies trading across borders to disclose the profits they make and the taxes they pay in every country where they operate. That way tax abuses could be quickly spotted.
• Multilateral, automatic exchange of tax information between governments, to help revenue authorities track down those seeking to dodge the taxes they owe by moving their money offshore.
• Jurisdictions worldwide to establish public records of ownership of each company, corporation, trust, partnership, limited liability partnership, charity and any other entity created under law.
Reforms called for by the Football Supporters’ Federation and Supporters Direct are:
• Every football club to reveal publicly the individuals who ultimately control it, regardless of domicile.
• A percentage of every club’s shares to be held by a not-for-profit supporters’ trust, entitling it to representation on the club’s board.
• A ‘tax’ on opaque ownership by ensuring that for each additional entity that a club has in its chain of control, a reduction is made in the amount it gets from its respective league.
– ends –
Notes to Editors:
1. Full details of tax haven Opacity Scores at www.financialsecrecyindex.com
2. Christian Aid works in some of the world’s poorest communities in nearly 50 countries. We act where the need is greatest, regardless of religion, helping people build the life they deserve.
3. Christian Aid has a vision – an end to poverty – and we believe that vision can become a reality. We urge you to join us. Our drive, Poverty Over, explains what we believe needs to be done – and can be done – to end global poverty. Details at www.christianaid.org.uk
4. Christian Aid is part of the ecumenical relief and development network
5. Follow Christian Aid’s newswire on Twitter: http://twitter.com/caid